What needs to be clarified
Compare the description with documented stages, distinguish project selection from representative selection and test the publication's terminology against the participation process.
Materials to prepare
- Project consultation rules and residents' voting form
- The complete results publication, headline and illustrations
- The result protocol and subsequent project-review documents
What to compare
Identify participants, offered options and what is counted. Check links to resource allocation, later authority decisions and implementing staff. Distinguish project support, recommendation and a governing mandate; relate conclusions to the specific rules without generalising one procedure to all civic participation.
Possible outcome of the analysis
A process diagram and terminology table may assess publication accuracy, identifying statements supported by documents and those conflating different participation mechanisms.
Limits of the conclusions
Selecting a project does not reveal political beliefs. Political analysis cannot establish legality, valid authority or representativeness for all residents without separate investigation of those questions.